Truth be told, Terry Holland may have already found East Carolina's next
football coach.
Before he
pulled the trigger on John Thompson,
the school's well-connected athletic director could have drafted a list,
worked the phones, and reached an informal agreement with his ace in the
hole.
If that's the case, ECU's long-term athletics fate has been signed,
sealed, and delivered. If not, Coach Holland hopefully is operating under
the assumption that he is in no position to gamble with the upcoming hire.
East Carolina simply lacks the chips to bet on an unknown.
That essentially is the path ECU took by
firing Steve Logan. In exchange for
a proven commodity that was to that moment in time the program's most
profitable investment, former chancellor Bill Muse and then-AD Mike Hamrick
bet the ranch on penny stocks.
Of the cards available drawn from a shallow deck of uninspiring
candidates Thompson emerged as a compromise of sorts, a reflection of the
lack of a solid plan by Muse and Hamrick for the program's future after
Logan.
Upon his hiring, even Thompson acknowledged the magnitude of the job that
had fallen into his lap.
"This football program has been
built on solid ground," Thompson
said at the time. "It is a
tremendous program with great tradition, great expectations. To come to a
place and be able to build upon that is truly an honor. There is so much
tradition in this place."
When the bottom dropped out the following September, a customarily
optimistic Pirate Nation that for the most part had been blindsided by
Logan's ouster spiraled quickly into a dark recession that has kept
Thompson on the defensive throughout his tenure.
That's the setting as Holland undertakes the task of hiring East
Carolina's next coach. It probably goes without saying that a mistake here
could magnify the steep recession into something akin to a depression.
That's why East Carolina would be well served to give Logan a call.
Granted, the chances of Logan returning to the Bagwell Field sideline are
about one in a hundred. However, if anyone is qualified to counsel Holland
on the qualities required for success in the stewardship of ECU's unique
football existence, it would have to be the the Pirates' most successful
coach in the I-A era.
Given Logan's demonstrated loyalty to East Carolina over the
years and the roots he's put down in the community, my guess is he'd help.
Regardless of anyone's position on Logan's firing, it's difficult to
question his blueprint for success, which parallels the bottom line in this
hiring equation:
Whomever Holland selects as his next coach must understand ECU's mission and
embrace its challenges.
With East Carolina's status as the state's only football school, Coach X
must be familiar with the pressures of working in a culture emotionally
dependent on gridiron success. Moreover, he also must have a grasp for
succeeding without some of the luxuries and advantages that are customary at
many schools.
In that regard, East Carolina is in small company. Southern Miss,
Marshall, and Boise State could be considered kindred programs, though none
have as many threatening neighbors in their back yard.
The candidate's ability to assemble an experienced, proven staff should
be atop Holland's checklist. The old adage that a head coach is only as good
as his assistants has unquestionable credence.
Even Florida State has had difficulty overcoming the defections of Bobby
Bowden's top lieutenants.
At East Carolina, the staff's responsibilities are much greater in
relative terms. Without a roster of blue chippers, so much is dependent upon
player development that one mistake in staff selection could mean the
difference in six wins and nine.
That said, ECU is in desperate need of a figure who can restore the
in-state recruiting bridges that Hamrick destroyed. Thompson's mission to
comb Florida first did little to repair the broken relationships that
resulted from the
Friday Night Fiasco.
"It's real gratifying the reception we get from the coaches here in this
state, and the local coaches in particular," Logan once said. "They now want
to see their kids play here.
"They know that they can jump in the car and come up here and watch the
kids play. That's a trust relationship that has cultivated over a 13-year
period now. We're real careful to keep cultivating that."
Ideally, Holland's hire will have an existing knowledge of the North
Carolina terrain and a commitment to outfitting local players in purple and
gold. From its inception as a program, East Carolina's foundation has been
in-state talent, a philosophy to which it must return.
This isn't to suggest that ECU shouldn't pursue the best talent available
or target kids across state lines. However, history has proven the Pirates
can win consistently with a nucleus of players from within a few hours
drive.
If all that isn't enough, Holland must lure a coach who measures high
enough on the wow meter to resonate with donors and excite potential season
ticket buyers. Anyone whose name doesn't make an immediate statement likely
won't rekindle the spark the Pirate Nation desperately needs.
That would seem to shrink the candidate pool considerably.
Of all the possibilities, former Marshall and Georgia coach Jim Donnan
would certainly qualify. He's worked in climates similar to Greenville on
both smaller and larger scales.
Donnan also is familiar with the region, has proven he can build a staff,
and would be a statement hire. Another attraction is the fact that East
Carolina likely would be a final stop given his age and experience.
If not Donnan, there are several coaches who closely emulate the mold.
Tommy West (Memphis), Dan Hawkins (Boise State), and Pat Hill (Fresno State)
immediately come to mind. Given the money Holland reportedly can spend,
chances are each would answer the phone.
Regardless, the type of calls Holland can't afford to make are those that
typified the search two years ago. Ideally, he will zero in on candidates
with the stature to galvanize the fanbase and help consolidate and leverage
the gains ECU's AD has already made in healing the rifts of the past.
Considering the urgency of stemming East Carolina's red ink and
positioning the program for inclusion in the next round of Big East
reconfiguration, this isn't the time to pursue a coach in training. There's
just too much riding on this decision to pick a wild card.